|
|
Post by San Jose Sharks on Jan 28, 2022 14:55:34 GMT -5
To Tampa Bay Lightning : Joe Sakic 94 F 5 YR (Whalers) Ryan Miller 89 G N/A YR (Rangers) 2009 2nd  2007 2nd  2009 2nd 2010 2nd To New York Rangers : Curtis Joseph 91 G 5 YR (Whalers) Radek Dvorak 83 F 10 YR (Habs) To San Jose Sharks : Saku Koivu 87 F 10 YR (Habs) Michael Ryder 85 F 11 YR (Habs) Ryan Clowe 84 F 12 YR (Habs) Jose Theodore 87 G 9 YR (Habs)  2005 1st *
From  Saku Koivu 87 F 10 YR Michael Ryder 85 F 11 YR Ryan Clowe 84 F 12 YR Radek Dvorak 83 F 10 YR Jose Theodore 87 G 9 YR 2005 1st * From Ryan Miller 89 G N/A YR 2009 2nd From Joe Sakic 94 F 5 YR Curtis Joseph 91 G 5 YR 2007 2nd 2009 2nd 2010 2nd
* - Condition: If Anaheim's 2005 1st round pick is 15th overall or worse, Hartford acquires Montreal's 2006 1st Round Pick. |
|
|
|
Post by Tampa Bay Lightning on Jan 28, 2022 15:08:43 GMT -5
Alright. Let me explain from NYR/MTL perspective - I'd make this deal 100% of the time on both ends.
Curtis Joseph 91 G 5 YR
Radek Dvorak 83 F 10 YR
for
Ryan Miller 89 G N/A YR
2009 2nd
Miller is a really good goalie until the end of the site. He's a very good controllable piece - so even though Joseph is rated higher, his lack of years makes him less valuable to me personally than Miller. Hence, the swap of Dvorak for a second offsets that difference.
Team perspective, the Rangers are looking to contend well now, so the addition of Joseph without giving up a 1st would be a good addition, especially adding in a solid depth forward. For the Habs, I'd rather have Miller than the two because of the longevity that Miller provides with all of the Canadiens long-term players creates a VERY solid core to supplement off of repeatedly.
Also, I think Ryan Miller would've rocked the Canadiens jersey.
Accepted
|
|
|
|
Post by New York Rangers on Jan 28, 2022 15:13:04 GMT -5
Alright. Let me explain from NYR/MTL perspective - I'd make this deal 100% of the time on both ends. Curtis Joseph 91 G 5 YR Radek Dvorak 83 F 10 YR for Ryan Miller 89 G N/A YR 2009 2nd Miller is a really good goalie until the end of the site. He's a very good controllable piece - so even though Joseph is rated higher, his lack of years makes him less valuable to me personally than Miller. Hence, the swap of Dvorak for a second offsets that difference. Team perspective, the Rangers are looking to contend well now, so the addition of Joseph without giving up a 1st would be a good addition, especially adding in a solid depth forward. For the Habs, I'd rather have Miller than the two because of the longevity that Miller provides with all of the Canadiens long-term players creates a VERY solid core to supplement off of repeatedly. Also, I think Ryan Miller would've rocked the Canadiens jersey. Accepted What he said. Accepted |
|
|
|
Post by Colorado Avalanche on Jan 28, 2022 15:18:33 GMT -5
Montreal is making out like a bandit in this deal.
|
|
|
|
Post by Winnipeg Jets on Jan 28, 2022 20:28:26 GMT -5
Montreal is making out like a bandit in this deal. possibly, I guess it depends on how you value the 5YRs. This trade is basically 94F for 87F & 85F and 91G for 87G & 84G The first being protected and likely to be bottom 10 has about as much value as the 3 2nds (maybe a tad more but it is negligible) so to me it comes down to does the fact the stars are only 5 years remaining justify this downgrade? I wont put my two cents on that here since that isn't my job but I wanted to break it down since it before I did it REALLY looked like a bad trade (I didn't even notice that Theodore was an 87 for a second lol). |
|
|
|
Post by Toronto Maple Leafs on Jan 29, 2022 16:50:44 GMT -5
FINALIZED
PROCESSED
|
|
